AI check: Example Roofing and Repair
Example, made-up business41 / 100
Patchy. AI tools know this business exists, but usually recommend someone else and get one detail wrong.
Sightlines
Each line is one AI tool looking for the business across 12 customer questions.
ChatGPTnamed 1 of 12, hours wrong
Gemininamed 3 of 12, service area missing
Claudenamed 1 of 12, service area missing
Perplexitynamed 2 of 12, hours wrong
Google Searchnamed 4 of 12, details right
Example Roofing(made-up business)
- Named, details right
- Named, a detail wrong or missing
- Not named
Results by tool
| ChatGPT | Gemini | Claude | Perplexity | Google Search | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Named (out of 12) | 1 | 3 | 1 | 2 | 4 |
| Hours right? | No | Yes | Yes | No | Yes |
| Phone right? | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Service area right? | Missing | Missing | Missing | Missing | Yes |
What we found
- ChatGPT says the business is closed Saturdays. The Google profile says open until noon.
- No AI tool could say which cities the business serves. The website lists them only in a map image.
- The contractors named most often had 150 to 400 Google reviews, a license number on their site and a page for each service. This business has 38 reviews and one services page.
- Nobody has claimed the business's free ChatGPT profile, so ChatGPT relies on Yelp and directory pages for its details.
Three fixes, most important first
- Correct Saturday hours on Yelp and two directories that ChatGPT cites.
- Write out service areas and the license number in plain text on the website and Google profile.
- Ask every customer for a review when the job is done, by text.